FIND HEALTH INSURANCE
Individual and Family
Employee Benefits
Medicare
Get a Quote
CONTACT US
1-833-342-5272 TTY: 711
8:30 am to 5:00 pm EST
Monday–Friday
our vision
Trusted relationships, simplifying insurance.
our mission
We customize health insurance solutions that balance your benefits and your budget, leaving you feeling confident in your decision. Your peace of mind is our priority. When you work with ARC, you come first.
who we are
No one client is the same and we don’t believe in a one-size-fits-all approach. You can rest assured knowing that we will find the right piece to your puzzle.
ARC’s licensed insurance agents are…
ARC’s business model was born two generations ago on handshake agreements and that’s how we do business today—by keeping our word. Our mission and company culture is based on integrity and excellence. At ARC Benefit Solutions we do what we say we are going to do and then some. As a family-run business, we believe our clients deserve not only excellence, but accountability, honesty, and empathy along with it. In this business, we pride ourselves on our determination to treat others with respect and deliver results exceeding our clients’ expectations as our core philosophy.
—Jennifer Agnello, President
our story
ARC Benefit Solutions is a family-owned business focused on simplifying the lives of our clients. Since 1985, we have made it our mission to get to know our clients’ needs so we can match them with the best insurance solution. Our cooperative approach enables us to get to know our clients and determine the best course of action for their coverage.
ARC Benefit Solutions is one of the Midwest’s largest agencies supporting more than 1,000 businesses. Our experts hold more than 150 licenses, certifications, and professional designations in the insurance industry.
our team
approachable • collaborative • creative • ethical • inclusive • meticulous • passionate • resourceful
employee benefits
Annie Carroll
Co-Owner
513-333-4434
Ryan Carroll
Co-Owner
513-629-2466
Jennifer Agnello
President
513-629-9340
Luke Boemker
Vice President, Sales Operations
513-629-9338
Paul Conroy
Director, Client Relations
513-629-9353
Kim Kinnaird
Director, Employee Benefits
567-302-2718
Scott Hetzel
Senior Benefit Consultant
513-751-1111
Andy Krull
Benefits Consultant
513-978-5875
Betsy Plymack
Client Relations Advisor
513-487-5393
Carla Winfrey
Client Relations Advisor
513-629-9356
Crystal Jones
Client Relations Advisor
567-302-2723
Evangeline Barnhart
Client Relations Advisor
740-592-0341
Hal Demmerle
Client Relations Advisor
513-629-9323
Jeremiah Knox
Client Relations Advisor
419-549-5078
Latonya Williams
Client Relations Advisor
567-302-2719
Melissa Costin
Client Relations Advisor
216-503-0499
Teresa Slater
Client Relations Advisor
513-333-4421
Stephanie McManis
Benefit Analyst
513-629-9348
Gina Gates
Client Relations Specialist
513-629-9320
individual/family and Medicare
Annie Carroll
Co-Owner
513-333-4434
Ryan Carroll
Co-Owner
513-629-2466
Jennifer Agnello
President
513-629-9340
Luke Boemker
Vice President, Sales Operations
513-629-9338
Rose Florez
Lead Client Care Advisor
866-712-8845
Aziz Rahman
Client Care Advisor
844-674-2005
Dale Geis
Client Care Advisor
888-476-5421
Jake Siemer
Client Care Advisor
844-217-3211
Judy Meier
Client Care Advisor
855-763-5142
Leslie Maxwell
Client Care Advisor
855-619-9796
Tom Mairose
Client Care Advisor
888-485-3652
Trina Shaw
Client Care Advisor
877-292-3867
Sheila Rust
Client Care Specialist
513-458-1465
our locations
Cincinnati (Headquarters)
2101 Florence Ave
Cincinnati, OH 45206
Cincinnati, OH 45206
Phone: 1-833-342-5272
HOURS OF OPERATION:
Monday through Friday
8:30 A.M. to 5:00 P.M.
Athens
Columbus
Dayton
Toledo
Northeast Ohio
ask us anything
Our licensed sales agents are available to answer your questions and concerns. Complete the form below and one of our agents will be in touch.
Or give us a ring at 1.833.DIAL.ARC TTY: 711
Mon.–Fri. 8:30 am–5:00 pm ET
Fill out my online form.